ABSTRACT
Non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) and vaccination are two fundamental approaches to mitigate the coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) pandemic. Vaccination strategies are generally less costly and socially/economically disruptive than NPI strategies, such as business closures, social distancing, and face mask mandates, as evidenced by highly vaccinated countries generally rolling back NPIs. However, the respective real-world impact of an NPI strategy versus vaccination strategy, or the combination of both, on mitigating Covid-19 transmission remains uncertain. To address this, we built a Bayesian inference model to explore the changing effectiveness of NPIs and vaccination based on the assembled large-scale dataset, including epidemiological parameters, variants, vaccines, and control variable. Here we show that NPIs were still considerably complementary or even synergistic to vaccination in the effort to curb the Covid-19 infection before reaching herd immunity. We found that (1) the synergistic effect of NPIs and vaccination was 46.9% (reduction in reproduction number) in September 2021, whereas the effects of NPIs and vaccination alone were 20.7% and 28.8%, respectively; (2) effectiveness of NPIs is less sensitive to emerging COVID-19 variants but decreases with vaccination progress, as NPIs may unnecessarily restrict the vaccinated population. The effectiveness of NPIs alone declined approximately 23% since the introduction of vaccination strategies, where the relaxation of NPIs promoted the decline from May 2021. Our results demonstrate that the decision to relax NPIs should consider the real-world vaccination rate of the relevant population, which is determined by the observed vaccine efficacy in relation to extant and emerging variants.
Subject(s)
COVID-19ABSTRACT
Worldwide governments have rapidly deployed non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic, together with the large-scale rollout of vaccines since late 2020. However, the effect of these individual NPI and vaccination measures across space and time has not been sufficiently explored. By the decay ratio in the suppression of COVID-19 infections, we investigated the performance of different NPIs across waves in 133 countries, and their integration with vaccine rollouts in 63 countries as of 25 March 2021. The most effective NPIs were gathering restrictions (contributing 27.83% in the infection rate reductions), facial coverings (16.79%) and school closures (10.08%) in the first wave, and changed to facial coverings (30.04%), gathering restrictions (17.51%) and international travel restrictions (9.22%) in the second wave. The impact of NPIs had obvious spatiotemporal variations across countries by waves before vaccine rollouts, with facial coverings being one of the most effective measures consistently. Vaccinations had gradually contributed to the suppression of COVID-19 transmission, from 0.71% and 0.86% within 15 days and 30 days since Day 12 after vaccination, to 1.23% as of 25 March 2021, while NPIs still dominated the pandemic mitigation. Our findings have important implications for continued tailoring of integrated NPI or NPI-vaccination strategies against future COVID-19 waves or similar infectious diseases.
Subject(s)
COVID-19ABSTRACT
Governments worldwide have rapidly deployed non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the effect of these individual NPI measures across space and time has yet to be sufficiently assessed, especially with the increase of policy fatigue and the urge for NPI relaxation in the vaccination era. Using the decay ratio in the suppression of COVID-19 infections, we investigated the changing performance of different NPIs across waves from global and regional levels (in 133 countries) to national and subnational (in the United States of America [USA]) scales before the implementation of mass vaccination. The synergistic effectiveness of all NPIs for reducing COVID-19 infections declined along waves, from 95.4% in the first wave to 56.0% in the third wave recently at the global level and similarly from 83.3% to 58.7% at the USA national level, while it had fluctuating performance across waves on regional and subnational scales. Regardless of geographical scale, gathering restrictions and facial coverings played significant roles in epidemic mitigation before the vaccine rollout. Our findings have important implications for continued tailoring and implementation of NPI strategies, together with vaccination, to mitigate future COVID-19 waves, caused by new variants, and other emerging respiratory infectious diseases.